Changing My EGR Valve
#4
Sounds like some mechanic is trying to drum up some business.. or you live in the WONDERFUL Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and have to contend to there retarded Emmission testing laws
One year they told me that i failed the Emmissions part but, if i pay the mechanic $200 towards repairs and it fails again then, i can get a waiver so it passes... WTF?
#5
Yes, I live in Pa, and Allegheny County requires emissions.
I have heard before that there is some way to wave the emissions if you spend a certain amount to fix it and it still doesn't pass, but I've never actually tried to look it up. To have the dealer replace the EGR, a solenoid on the charcoal canister, and the fuel gage sending unit the quote was already $1700 and they said nothing about being able to wave emissions. So, I'm replacing the parts myself. $1700 is absolutely nuts!
I have heard before that there is some way to wave the emissions if you spend a certain amount to fix it and it still doesn't pass, but I've never actually tried to look it up. To have the dealer replace the EGR, a solenoid on the charcoal canister, and the fuel gage sending unit the quote was already $1700 and they said nothing about being able to wave emissions. So, I'm replacing the parts myself. $1700 is absolutely nuts!
#6
So do I have to pull the manifold to change it, or can I get to it the way it is?
#8
Yes, I live in Pa, and Allegheny County requires emissions.
I have heard before that there is some way to wave the emissions if you spend a certain amount to fix it and it still doesn't pass, but I've never actually tried to look it up. To have the dealer replace the EGR, a solenoid on the charcoal canister, and the fuel gage sending unit the quote was already $1700 and they said nothing about being able to wave emissions. So, I'm replacing the parts myself. $1700 is absolutely nuts!
I have heard before that there is some way to wave the emissions if you spend a certain amount to fix it and it still doesn't pass, but I've never actually tried to look it up. To have the dealer replace the EGR, a solenoid on the charcoal canister, and the fuel gage sending unit the quote was already $1700 and they said nothing about being able to wave emissions. So, I'm replacing the parts myself. $1700 is absolutely nuts!
1. The vehicle has under 5000 miles from last inspection or
2. minimum $200 in emission related repairs are made and the vehicle still fails.
Personally i think that emissions is a total BS, just a way for the state to screw ya.
#9
I went back to the shop yesterday, and they said if I spend $150 (that's what I found online too was the 150 number) I can wave the emissions. I went to Advance Auto for the EGR valve, for the AC Delco valve it was $240. So I'm good.
The thing that pisses me off about the emissions testing is it's by county. And it's completely different tests for different counties. Around Philly they do a true emissions test where they run the car on a dyno and have a wand in the exhaust pipe to measure what comes out. In Erie they do a sniffer test on the gas cap. Here in Pittsburgh they just plug the computer in and check for emissions codes. It is all BS!
The thing that pisses me off about the emissions testing is it's by county. And it's completely different tests for different counties. Around Philly they do a true emissions test where they run the car on a dyno and have a wand in the exhaust pipe to measure what comes out. In Erie they do a sniffer test on the gas cap. Here in Pittsburgh they just plug the computer in and check for emissions codes. It is all BS!
#10
In Texas it is the same way... Emissions. And supposedly it will be expanding innto teh further out counties here too. No one will be safe... Augh! I rather they just plug into my computer. That way I can do away with my cats and delete my rear O2 sensors. And possibly delete the EGR too.